• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

NYC Pizza Company: Authentic New York-Style Pizza in Duluth, GA

NYC Pizza Company, nestled in Duluth, GA, serves authentic New York-style pizza with a focus on quality ingredients and a perfectly savory, light crust. This spot shines through its classic offerings like the meat lover’s and Bianca pizzas, delighting even skeptics with its unique take on Hawaiian. The warm, inviting atmosphere is enhanced by friendly, attentive staff and refreshing draft Peroni. Beyond pizza, their dessert—especially the banana cookie butter pie—leaves a lasting impression. With genuine care evident in every slice, NYC Pizza Company delivers a heartfelt, memorable dining experience that resonates with both East Coast authenticity and Southern hospitality.

NYC Pizza Company at a glance

  • Address 2200 Peachtree Industrial Blvd #110, Duluth, GA 30097, United States
  • Phone +1 470-336-7874
  • Restaurant type Restaurant , Italian restaurant , Pizza delivery , Pizza restaurant .

Photos & Gallery

NYC Pizza Company: Reviews & Ratings

Guillermo Maduro
5

Best NY-style pizza around. No gimmicks: just quality ingredients and a deliciously savory crust. I've tried all their varieties; my favorite is the meat lover's followed by the bianca. I was a Hawaiian-pizza hater until I tried their version with smaller pineapple chunks and quality ham. For a memorable dining experience, ask for Ms. Diana.

LD East2233
5

Just wow. You can try too hard to find legitimate pizza, yet just go here and enjoy. If you like NY pizza, they even serve Junior’s cheesecake. Their pizza passes the non-flop/ single hand fold test. Excellent! Cheyenne represents this place with exuberance and makes this place cool to enjoy a slice.

James Rogers
5

Great pizza. Draft Peroni. Very friendly staff. Happy hour weekdays 3pm to 6pm (check with restaurant for veracity and continuity). Really enjoyed our pizza and beer!

ATL Reviews With A Bite!
4

NYC Pizza Company delivers truly delicious pizza. The light crust, fantastic tomato sauce, and fresh ingredients create a very satisfying pie, and I've experienced consistently excellent food quality across two visits. My initial takeout was great, with top-notch service from an older gentleman at the counter – the kind of seasoned pro who clearly knows his stuff! The dine-in atmosphere is enjoyable with a great vibe and a clean, open kitchen, and the draft Peroni is a refreshing touch. However, there's a clear opportunity for improvement in service (our waitress seemed more focused on her phone) and management (the TV was oddly stuck on local news when sports would have been preferred). While it's a solid spot for the suburbs, expanding the menu to include more traditional Italian dishes like Chicken Marsala and Veal Parmesan. Also, adding a bar area would significantly elevate the overall experience, especially for those waiting on to-go orders.

Nia Livs
5

I didn’t walk in with much and I left with more than I expected plus a stomach and heart full I wish I’d gotten the name of the man who served us but I’ll never forget his face. He greeted us through the window before we even walked in. He’s due a better tip for his servitude, kindness, and genuine care. The owner/manager prides himself for the cleanliness of their restaurant which I attest to. The pizza was bomb, the banana cookie butter pie sent my little one and myself to the third heavens. I felt I was back East. Thank you all for your kindness and food saturated in passion May your business continue to thrive and know you spread gratitude among the hearts of those honored to experience what you offer the world

Michael Davis
5

The pizza is delicious. Imagine having so many pepperonis on a single slice that you almost consider not eating it... almost. The flavors are great and the prices are, too. Everyone was friendly and our server smiled as the mozzarella cheese pull from my bite stretched almost arms length. If I lived closer, I'd be here every week. Try it!

Location

  • NYC Pizza Company
    NYC Pizza Company
    2200 Peachtree Industrial Blvd #110, Duluth, GA 30097, United States Hotline: +1 470-336-7874

Located in Duluth, GA, NYC Pizza Company brings an authentic slice of New York right to the suburbs. This pizzeria stands out for its commitment to quality ingredients and that quintessential NY-style crust—light, crisp, and perfectly savory. From the very first bite, it's clear that this isn’t just any pizza joint; it’s a place where tradition meets passion.

Their menu caters to a variety of tastes, with the meat lover’s pie earning high praise for its balance of hearty toppings, while the bianca pizza offers a clean, flavorful alternative. Even skeptics of Hawaiian pizza find themselves converted, thanks to the carefully selected smaller pineapple chunks and quality ham that elevate this classic. Each slice embodies the rich, bold flavors characteristic of an authentic New York pie.

Beyond the pizza, NYC Pizza Company impresses with its warm, genuine service. Customers repeatedly highlight the attentiveness and kindness of the staff, who create a welcoming atmosphere that enriches every visit. The dine-in experience benefits from an open, clean kitchen and a lively vibe, perfectly complemented by draft Peroni that refreshes the palate.

The inclusion of Junior’s cheesecake pays homage to New York’s sweet treats, adding another layer of authenticity and delight. The banana cookie butter pie is a standout dessert that lingers in memory, offering a sweet conclusion that feels handcrafted with care.

While the atmosphere is inviting, some guests see room for growth—with improved service focus, a more engaging bar area, and an expanded Italian-inspired menu potentially elevating the experience further. However, these minor notes do little to diminish the overall joy of dining here.

What truly resonates is the sense of passion infused into every dish and interaction. NYC Pizza Company is more than a pizzeria—it’s a heartfelt tribute to New York’s rich culinary spirit, right in the heart of Georgia. Whether you're chasing nostalgia for East Coast flavors or simply craving honest, expertly crafted pizza, this spot delivers on all fronts with grace and flavor.